My favorite Pizza in AZ, NYPD. It really is the closest to NY pizza, I should know, I grew up eating the stuff :)
The also have canolis and zeppoles for dessert. This one is in Peoria at 83rd Ave & Union Hills. They have several in the valley and all decorated a little different, but the main theme is the same-subway walls, street signs and the classic tiny floor tiles (that are exactly the same as the ones in our bathroom in Queens)